Skip to main content
European Commission logo
International Partnerships

Mid-term evaluation of 3R4UB project

This evaluation reviews the 3R4UB project’s performance, analysing progress, delays and feasibility of planned results, and identifying factors affecting implementation to inform the decision on the requested no-cost extension.

Evaluation

Details

Identification
EvalRef 2022-M-3850, Evaluation contract - 300054505 - 440919, Evaluated references C-415305
Publication date
7 June 2023
Author
Directorate-General for International Partnerships

Description

The mid-term evaluation assesses the EU-funded 3R4UB project supporting Ulaanbaatar in improving municipal solid waste management through capacity building, awareness, planning tools and construction of a material recovery facility. The project aligns strongly with national and municipal waste strategies and EU circular economy principles. 

After a slow start caused by COVID-19 and a full change of municipal staff, implementation accelerated following the 2022 ROM review. Training under Work Package 3 was fully delivered to 20 participants, including online modules and a study tour in Italy. Awareness activities expanded through social media, events and a relaunch of the website. A pref feasibility study for a green investment fund was completed. 

However, significant delays persist in the procurement and construction of the waste facility, a core component necessary to achieve results. Budget constraints, cost inflation, unclear EIA requirements and limited procurement capacity pose additional risks. 

Efficiency has improved but coordination with stakeholders, reporting and monitoring remains uneven. Impact is still too early to assess, as most output-level achievements depend on the plant construction. Sustainability shows potential through training and joint development of a waste master plan, but continuity will require stronger institutional engagement. 

The evaluation concludes that results are achievable only with a 12-month no-cost extension and improved risk management, coordination and budgeting.

Files